Question

Reciting Tashahhud after Sujood as-Sahw in Hanbali School

523

Question

Assalaamu alaykum, Shaykh. Thanks for responding, but your reply did not answer my question; I asked you whether is it obligatory or just Sunnah to recite Tashahud after Sujood Sahw (prostration of forgetfulness) if it is done after the Tasleem (ending the prayer with the Salaam greeting) according to the Hanbali school?

Related Fatwa

Ruling on repeating the takbeer when moving from sujood to standing if the initial takbeer was cut off

What to do if one raises his head during Sujood intending to sit for Tashahud, then realizes halfway through the Takbeer that he is in the wrong Rak'ah?

Made a mistake in the Prostration of Forgetfulness - what to do?

Fumbled in Taslim and Repeated As-Salam Alaikum

Said Takbeer after Prostration Late and His Father Raised His Head Before Hearing Him

Praying Behind an Imam Who Does Not Put His Nose on the Ground when Prostrating

When to Point with the Index Finger in Prayer and When to Perform the Prostrations for Forgetfulness

Accepted Answer

All perfect praise be to Allah, The Lord of the worlds. I testify that there is none worthy of worship except Allah and that Muhammad, sallallahu ‘alayhi wa sallam, is His slave and Messenger.

The Hanbalis held that it is obligatory (Waajib) to recite Tashahhud after the Sujood as-Sahw that is performed after the Tasleem, as is stated in their books. Even if the person forgot to perform Sujood as-Sahw before Tasleem and he performed it after Tasleem, he has to recite Tashahhud as an obligation, according to them.

In his commentary on the Fiqh book Al-Muqni’, the Hanbali scholar Ibn Muflih said:

“...When he performs Sujood as-Sahw after Tasleem, regardless of whether he was supposed to perform it after Tasleem or before it but he forgot and then performed it after Tasleem, he must recite the final Tashahhud as an obligation. This is the view of a group of scholars including Ibn Mas‘ood, as evidenced by the hadeeth narrated on the authority of ‘Imraan, who reported that the Prophet, sallallahu ‘alayhi wa sallam, forgot (something), so he performed two prostrations and then recited the Tashahhud and then made Tasleem... [Abu Dawood; At-Tirmithi - At-Tirmithi graded it hasan (good)] Moreover, he should recite the Tashahhud (after Sujood as-Sahw) because it is a prostration that requires Tasleem, so it has to be followed by the Tashahhud and then Tasleem, just like the obligatory, final Tashahhud of the prayer ... Another view holds that one should not recite Tashahhud in this case, just like the Sujood as-Sahw before Tasleem, and this view was chosen by Shaykh Taqiyy Ad-Deen (Ibn Taymiyyah).” [Sharh Al-Muqni’]

Allah knows best.

Fatwa

Reciting Tashahhud after Sujood as-Sahw in Hanbali School

Question

Answer

Related Fatwa

Ruling on repeating the takbeer when moving from sujood to standing if the initial takbeer was cut off

What to do if one raises his head during Sujood intending to sit for Tashahud, then realizes halfway through the Takbeer that he is in the wrong Rak'ah?

Made a mistake in the Prostration of Forgetfulness - what to do?

Fumbled in Taslim and Repeated As-Salam Alaikum

Said Takbeer after Prostration Late and His Father Raised His Head Before Hearing Him

Praying Behind an Imam Who Does Not Put His Nose on the Ground when Prostrating

When to Point with the Index Finger in Prayer and When to Perform the Prostrations for Forgetfulness

Search Fatwa

Fatwa Subject

Categories

Multimedia

Special Folders

Services