All perfect praise be to Allaah, The Lord of the Worlds. I testify that there is none worthy of worship except Allaah, and that Muhammad,
, is His slave and Messenger.
We have already clarified the definition of Bid'ah (innovation in religion) and the meaning of a Bid'ah Hasanah (good innovation) in Fataawa 2741, 17613 and 91407.
However, the Ahaadeeth that you have mentioned are not evidence for the Sufis for their innovation. Bilaal,
, had performed a permissible act of worship which is the prayer, and when he performed it after ablution and the Prophet,
, approved this act, we knew that this act was permissible after ablution, whereas the Sufis do an impermissible act of worship which is celebrating the Mawlid (birthday of the Prophet,
).
On the other hand, Ibn Hajar,
, said that it is permissible to make Ijtihaad (personal diligence) in allocating a time for an act of worship but he did not say that it is permissible to make Ijtihaad in innovating a new act of worship, and the story of Khabbaab proves this.
As regards the mention of Allaah that the Companion said when he raised his head from Ruku’, when the Prophet,
, approved this act, we knew that this act was permissible, and it was at the time of legislation [revelation being sent down] when a Companion may do an act or say a statement and it will be approved from him (i.e. by the Prophet,
). Having said that, a Companion may do an act or say a statement and it will not be approved from him as what happened when Al-Baraa’ ibn ‘Aaazib,
, was taught by the Prophet,
, to say the supplication for going to sleep which includes “…and your Prophet, whom You have sent,” and Al-Baraa’ changed the wording saying “…and your Messenger, whom You have sent.” So, the Prophet,
, did not approve of this wording and told him “'No, and your Prophet whom You have sent'.” [Al-Bukhari]
Therefore, the Sufis comparing their innovation to what Bilaal and Khabbaab,
, did is an inappropriate analogy.
Allaah Knows best.