Seeing the Prophet in a dream

7-4-2011 | Islamweb

Question:
Is it a condition for the validity of seeing the Prophet, sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam, in a dream that a person sees him, sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam, exactly as he was described in the Sunnah? If a person sees the Prophet, sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam, in a vision, but some of his features were different, for example, non-bearded, would this mean that it is not the Prophet, sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam?

Answer:

All perfect praise be to Allaah, The Lord of the Worlds. I testify that there is none worthy of worship except Allaah, and that Muhammad, , is His slave and Messenger.

 

The Messenger of Allaah, , said that when a person sees him in a dream, then he has actually seen him, because the devil cannot embody the image of the Prophet, . [Muslim]

Ibn Hajar, , said that although Allaah The Almighty enabled the devil to embody the image of any person he wants, He did not enable him to embody the image of the Prophet, .

Some scholars said that the vision mentioned in the abovementioned Hadeeth is valid only if a person saw the Prophet, , in his realistic form. Some scholars said that he must be seen in his last image, when he was dying, and that he must even see the grey hairs of the Prophet, , that did not amount to twenty. However, Ibn Hajar, , believed that the correct opinion is that a person is considered to have seen the Prophet, , if he sees him in any of his images, meaning, in his youth, manhood, early middle age, or during his last days on earth. If a person does not see the Prophet, , in any of his images, then this may have some kind of particular significance concerning that person. This is understood from the words of Ibn Hajar, .

Al-Qaraafi, , said:

Seeing the Prophet, , in a dream is valid for only two categories of people:

1-    A Companion of the Prophet, , who saw him , , in real life. When this Companion sees the Prophet, , in a vision, he will have no doubt that he is seeing the Prophet, .

2-    A person who listens several times to the description of the Prophet, . When this person sees him, , in a vision, he will have no doubt that he is seeing the Prophet, , exactly like those who lived during the time of the Prophet, .

 If a person does not belong to either of these two categories, he cannot be sure that he saw the Prophet, , in a vision. If he sees the Prophet, , there are two possibilities:

1-    He may have seen the Prophet, .

2-    The devil may have made him believe that he saw the Prophet, .

This person must not be sure, even if he sees a man in his dream who tells him that he is indeed the Prophet, , and even if a person accompanying that man in the vision tells him that this man is the Prophet, . This is because the devil lies about himself and to others.

If a person does not see the Prophet, , in any of his forms, then this may be interpreted in a certain way that suits the condition of that person. For example, if he sees the Prophet, , with black skin, this means that the person is unfair. If he sees the Prophet, , blind, this means the person does not have faith. If he sees the Prophet, , without hands, this means the person prevents the implementation of the Sharee‘ah. If he sees the Prophet, , non-bearded, this means the person derides the Prophet, . If this person sees the Prophet, , as an old man, this mean the person respects the Prophet, . [End of quote].

This is what is understood from the words of Al-Qaraafi, .

Allaah Knows best.

www.islamweb.net