Fatwas (40)
I read in a book "It is permissible for one to ask that one's duas[supplications, prayers] be accepted for the sake of the Awliyâ[Dear slaves of Allahu ta’âlâ]." What is meant by this, i havent heard it before?
More
As-Subki quoted the following from Ibn Al-‘Arabi: "But the visitor of a grave should not seek to benefit from the deceased, because this is an innovation. Benefiting is only allowed from the grave of Prophet Muhammad and other Prophets." [Sharh Al-Muwatta by Ibn Al-‘Arabi, As-Saarim Al-Munki chapter 4] Ibn Abdul-Haadi replied in great detail. Please, if you could summarize his answer, it would be a great help for the Muslim community, especially for those who speak English.
More
I have been married for 8 months now. My husband told me that he asked a person in their grave to supplicate for him once or twice a long time ago. He told me about this incident after our marriage, and I told him that it constitutes polytheism. So he immediately sought forgiveness and considered it to be polytheism. My question is whether our marriage is valid or not? We got married before he repented. He also told me that he used to seek forgiveness from Allah for many things, but he did not remember whether he sought forgiveness for...
More
Please read this question and answer me, even if the answer is only yes or no. If I follow the opinion of a certain man, for example, that the one who asks an absent or dead person for something that not only Allaah can do is not a disbeliever, and if I do not know which deeds are meant with this sentence, and another scholar says that asking a dead person to fulfil his need is disbelief, is it permissible for me to say, 'I do not know if asking a dead person to fulfil his need is disbelief because...
More
Why do we say that it is disbelief to ask the dead to fullfil someone's need but we do not say that it is disbelief to ask the dead to ask Allaah? In both cases, the caller is calling/supplicating the dead, and in both cases, the caller is asking the dead for something which he can not do, and in both cases, the caller thinks that the dead can do this by the will of Allaah. For example, if he asks the dead to fullfil his need, like by saying, 'Help me,' he thinks that the soul can come and help...
More
What is the ruling on speaking with a devil, animal, stone, or a person who might be present? What I mean with the first is, if a man wants to pray and says loadly or silently in his heart, "I will pray and you (satan) will not prevent me from it." What I mean with the second is saying to an animal, "O such-and-such, you are so cute," or calling the animal with a name so that the animal comes close to you, while the animal is ignorant about this name. What I mean with the third is saying to...
More
Assalamu alaykum wa rahmatullaahi wa barakaatuh. Shaykh, is the following hadith authentic? If yes, then it proves that the dead can pray for those who are alive. Mufti Aashiq Ilahi, on page 18 in his book What Happens after Death, quotes At-Tabaraani as having reported that the Prophet Muhammad, sallallaahu 'alayhi wa sallam, said, "Your deeds and actions are undoubtedly presented to your relatives who have gone to the Hereafter. If your deeds are virtuous, they become happy and pray to Allaah for your welfare and a happy end. If bad deeds are presented, they pray to Allaah for infusing virtues in...
More
I believe that going to the Prophet's grave or the grave of a righteous man and asking them to make dua to Allah for you is in innovation in the religion, However, on a forum I frequent, one person claimed that it is mentioned in Fath Al-Bari that the majority of the scholars say that the dead can hear the living, and that person also claims that the majority of the scholars, such as Abul-Haamid Al-Ghazaali, Ibn Qudaama, Al-Mawsili Al-Hanafi, Zahirud-Din Abu Shuja', An-Nawawi, Shihabud-Din Al-Qarafi, Ibnul-Hajj, Ibn Farhun Al-Maaliki, Ibn Jamaa'ah, Ibn Zamlikaani, and As-Samhudi, wrote in their books that...
More
Assalaamu alaykum wa rahmatullaahi wa barakaatuh. Shaykh, is the following quote authentic? Apparently, it was quoted from Ibn Taymiyyah's work: A person came to the blessed grave of the Messenger of Allaah, sallallaahu 'alayhi wa sallam, and requested food from the Prophet, sallallaahu 'alayhi wa sallam, and sat down. After a while, a Hashimi (a member of the Prophet’s, sallallaahu 'alayhi wa sallam family) came to him. He had a tray of food with him and said, "This food has been sent by the Prophet, sallallaahu 'alayhi wa sallam, along with the following message: Eat it and leave because whoever loves us does not...
More
AslamualakuumI asked this question before but you reffered me to anothe fatwa that didnt answer it.some people say they call upon Jesus, Prophet Muhammad, big schollars, this person and that person, and they say that there duas get accepted. What is this, is it jinn, is it Allah misguding them. My brohter said to me that he read that Ibn taymiah wrote about this, he said somoe body was in trouble and called upon him (ibn taumiah), and he was saved, ibn taymiah then states that he didnt hear his call neither did he help him, he said it was...
More
Assalam alaikum wrwb I would like to know if it is shirk to call our "Jesus" if something happens to a person. For instance, you see something surprising or you see something shocking or something happens in which the first word that comes out of the mouth is "Jesus" due to hearing it being said by non-Muslims. Is this a form of shirk and apostasy or is this considered not a big sin. I amassing not because I say this but because I hear many Muslims calling out "Jesus" when something happens. May Allah reward you ameen
More
AsSalam Alikum, What is the meaning of "Labbaik Ya Rasool Allah"? Are People say this coz of greeting or for supplication? Confused!
More
what Ibn Hajar Haytami said in Fatawa Hadeethiya page 342 answer to the question no. 118, and Manawi in Faydh al Qadeer 3/400 no. 3700, and Abu Bakar bin Tahir as quoted by Qadhi Iyaad in Ash-Shifa regarding the meaning of the hadeeth "Your deeds are presented to me. I f they are good, I express my gratitude to Allāh, and if the deeds are not good, then I pray to Allāh for your forgiveness" all the above statements are in arabic in your arabic fatawa no. 142177 It will clear the that this hadeeth does not mean to ask...
More
Assalamu alikum Could you please tell us what Imam ad-Dahabi said in Tareekh al Islam under the biography of Sultan bin Mahmood Balbaki the Zaahid. And in it he quoted a story by Shaykh Saaleh Mahmood bin Sultan. That Allah listened to the prayer at his grave. JazakAllahukhayran
More
Among the followed means in my society in seeking cure is going to the shrines of the righteous people. Some people claim that whoever is afflicted with paralysis or any other disease has only to stay overnight at the shrine of a certain Shaykh. Moreover, someone claims that he knows a person who was paralyzed and spent the night at one of these shrines and in the morning of the next day he was healed and could walk on his own.
What is the ruling under Sharee‘ah on these claims? How can we convince them that their acts are invalid...
More
Search Fatwa You can search for fatwa through many choices
Fatwa