Question
Assalamo alaykum wa rahmato Allah, As Shaikh Qaradawi (may Allah protect him) has mentioned in a previous fatwa in 2003, if an anaesthetic is not used to kill the animal but rather to prevent it from moving while it is being slaughtered, it is lawful and its meat can be eaten by Muslims. There is a new law in the Netherlands which stipulates that slaughtering animals be only practiced after anesthetizing the animal. Once the new law is implemented, any slaughtering of animals without anesthetization will be considered a violation of law. This “violation” (normal Islamic slaughtering) will subject one to a penalty (e.g. a fine). A Muslim who lives in the West should abide by regulations applied in the country where he lives as long as it does not contradict Shari'a. Furthermore, safeguarding oneself and one's property is an Islamic obligation. Is there any objection to the Muslim’s acceptance or support of this new Dutch law on the basis of the fatwa that allows eating meat of animals that were anaesthetized, as long as the anaesthetic does not cause the death of the animal? Is this like supporting a law that makes lawful slaughtering (by cutting the throat) into something “haram” (without anaesthetics)? The new law will also make the Muslim minority in the Netherlands dependent on the availability of anaesthetics in the country in ‘eid al adha’, when the demand for slaughtering is high among Muslims. No anaesthetics will mean no ‘eid al adha’. Jazakum Allah khayran. Hicham Abbassi


Search Fatwa 

