Question
This is going to be a rather lengthy email. Please forgive but I want to give details if you allow me. 3 years ago my father passed away. My family consists of my mother, we are three brothers and one sister. Prior to his death, one of his assets, a shop was being rented by my sister and she paid approx 17000-20000/month rent to him. The other half of the shop was rented to a non-family member who paid my father about 8-10 000/month. Approximately 7-8 weeks before his death, while healthy and in sound mental ability he got upset at my sister and telephonically told her that she should get out of the shop.
While he was in hospital, he told me that the shop was for his three sons only and not for the females.
After he passed on we discovered that he had Not left an Islamic will. In the will he excluded me (youngest son (A) and my mother (K) from any inheritance. He left the shop to my sister (R) and to the middle brother (H) half-half. He left policies valuing approx R400 000 to eldest brother (M.A). He left flat and cars to granddaughters I encouraged the family to ignore un-Islamic will and to distribute estate Islaamicly.
The estate at the time of his death included. Shop (+/- 3 - 4 million), Flat (residence) +/- 350-400 000, Cars (+/- 150 000), Cash 200 000, Other assets (estimate 100000)
Other assets which I don't know about.
This is what "my brother (H) and sister (R)" did. They valued the shop at 1 million and ignoring all other assets divided the shop into "Islamic shares". From their calculation my share was worth 246 000 (123 000 from sisters half of shop and 123 000 from brothers half) and they said that this is the amount they were going to pay out to me (A) and eldest brother (MA). I mentioned that I did not want to sell my share of the shop but they (R) and (H) refused to accept this. My sister gave me 123 000 but I returned it and my brother also gave me 12300 but I needed the money and took it. However I told them subsequently that the value was too low, and that they couldn't force me into selling my share of the shop. I offered to pay them (R) and (H) 123 000 each and they should sell their shares to me but obviously they both refused. None of the other assets were distributed.
3 years after my father's death from his estate this is what the picture looks like.
My sister has part of shop (slightly bigger) which at today's rate would pay 25-35 000/month. My brother (H) has the other part of shop and he collects 12 000/month rent. My sister has in the last two years bought a flat worth 800 000, a car worth 250 000, taken her family overseas thrice. My brother (H) is semi retired, bought a flat worth 900 000, a house worth 600 000 (but he had money before my father died). The eldest brother took the money (246 000) plus monies from policies worth 400 000. My mother got 50 000 from cash part of estate.
I received 123 000 from brother H that's all and refused the money from my sister. My brother-in-law sols his own shop about 3 months after my father's death and joined my sister in the shop.
About a month ago I found out that the holiday flat in Durban was registered under my name. For this reason it was not included in father's estate. But, my father when he was alive told the whole family that this flat was for all the children and it was his wish that it should not be sold but used by all kids and that we the kids should live peacefully.
The flat if sold today should be able to fetch 1.5-1.7 million. Alternatively, if rented could get about 5000/month Can I sell this flat and will the money be permissible for me. I estimate that when my father died 3 years ago the rental from the shop was around 30000 month. Today around 40000 month. If I didn't want to sell my share of the shop and still don't, but being realistic after pleading with my family about the will, they are Not going to change anything and taking into account that all that I have received 123 000 so far can I sell this Durban flat and tell brothers and sister that I'm taking the money from the flat in-law of my share in shop. The share in the shop is much more in value than the value of the flat.
I am the youngest in my family. For the past 3 years none of them once had the guts to say that what I got from my father's estate was unjust. They are all leading easy/luxurious lives. I have just completed my studies and they all know that I need the money. I feel hurt and very disgusted at my siblings. What should I do?


Search Fatwa 

